Session

Transgender and Gender Expansive People's Health Part 2: Qualitative Research

Brittany Charlton, ScD, Harvard Medical School and Boston Children's Hospital, Boston, MA and Kristi Gamarel, PhD, Department of Health Behavior & Health Education, University of Michigan School of Public Health, Ann Arbor, MI

APHA's 2020 VIRTUAL Annual Meeting and Expo (Oct. 24 - 28)

Abstract

Recognizing social policing as structural violence and a determinant of health among transgender women sex workers in lima, Peru

Amaya Perez-Brumer, PhD, MSc1, Alfonso Silva-Santisteban, MD, MPH2, Sarah Naz-McLean, MPH3, Ximena Salazar, PhD, MA2, Ho Amat y Leon Puño, MA2, Jana Villayzan Aguilar, MPH4 and Sari Reisner, ScD5
(1)University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada, (2)Universidad Peruana Cayetano Heredia, Lima, Peru, (3)Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Boston, MA, (4)RedTrans, Lima, Peru, (5)Fenway Health, Boston, MA

APHA's 2020 VIRTUAL Annual Meeting and Expo (Oct. 24 - 28)

Background: In Peru, the absence of laws that protect transgender communities and/or laborers in informal erotic economies, transgender women sex workers (TWSW) experience extreme social dislocation and violence.

Methods: Between October 2015-October 2016, 104 incidents of violence (IV) reported by TWSW were collected in Lima, Peru. Using critical discourse analysis, IV were thematically coded and analyzed to assess violence type perpetrated, geographic clustering, and interpersonal dynamics. IV were subsequently triangulated with data derived from discussions with 42 TWSW and local law enforcement officers. Audio files were transcribed verbatim and analyzed using Dedoose (v.6.1.18).

Results: Narratives describe high levels of structural, physical, and symbolic violence through systemic social policing practices, meaning the enactment of structural and symbolic violence by neighbors, clients, police, peers perpetrated against people who traverse multiple marginalized statuses (e.g., transgender women, sex worker, economically disenfranchised, etc.). Majority of participants described these practices as violence associated with harm to their physical and mental health, and impacted overall mistrust in social institutions, such as, healthcare. Two key themes further demonstrated the intersection between social policing and violence as a structural determinant of health for TWSW: (1) structural violence, including institutionalized surveillance and persecution resulting in arrest, incarceration, and exploitative labor practices; and (2) enacted physical and symbolic violence including assault, forced sex, kidnapping, and extortion.

Conclusion: Findings underscore the need for human rights-based public health strategies to address these emerging dimensions of structural violence (e.g., cis-/heteronormative and informal economy social policing) confronted by TWSW in Peru and globally.

Public health or related laws, regulations, standards, or guidelines Public health or related research Social and behavioral sciences

Abstract

Transgender individuals and intimate partner violence: An in-depth perspective

Jeanine P.D. Guidry, Ph.D.1, Ashlee Sawyer, Ph.D., M.P.H.1, Shana Meganck, Ph.D.2, Iccha Basnyat, Ph.D.2 and Viktor Nowack, M.S.1
(1)Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, VA, (2)James Madison University, Harrisonburg, VA

APHA's 2020 VIRTUAL Annual Meeting and Expo (Oct. 24 - 28)

Studies have shown that transgender adults report poorer health than the general population and are less likely to seek out healthcare services. Healthcare providers have started routine screening for Intimate Partner Violence (IPV), because transgender individuals are less likely to seek healthcare services, they experience additional barriers in this area as well, while having a lifetime prevalence of IPV ranging between 31-50%. While the typical types of IPV among cisgender people also take place in trans relationships, there are several additional areas of vulnerability for transgender people, for example threatening to disclose the transgender individual’s gender identity to others who may respond negatively.

This study uses a qualitative research approach in the form of 30 in-depth interviews with transgender individuals. Participants are currently being recruited in collaboration with several Virginia-based community partners that offer services to LGBTQ+ individuals.

RQ1: What are transgender individuals’ experiences and coping mechanisms with IPV?

RQ2: What impacts transgender individuals’ choice to seek or avoid help with IPV?

While this study is ongoing, the implications are already apparent: The study results will provide a greater understanding of the health care and health care delivery needs for transgender individuals related to IPV; the study participants are able to share their story and help increase knowledge about issues affecting this vulnerable population; and the collaboration with community partners provides the opportunity for the using information in future transgender messaging and intervention strategies.

Assessment of individual and community needs for health education Public health or related research Social and behavioral sciences

Abstract

Transgender and non-binary patient perspectives on receiving transition-related healthcare in family planning clinics in the United States

Natalie Ingraham, MPH, PhD, Andrés González, BA, Aerin Riegelsberger, BA and Lindsey Fox
CSU East Bay, Hayward, CA

APHA's 2020 VIRTUAL Annual Meeting and Expo (Oct. 24 - 28)

Background: Although some research exists at the intersection of reproductive health and transgender health, little research has explored the expansion of transgender healthcare within family planning clinics. This paper describes findings from a national qualitative research project on transgender care in family planning clinics from the perspectives of transgender and non-binary patients. Methods: In-depth interviews with 22 transgender and non-binary people over age 18 who had recieved transition-related care at a family planning clinic in the last year. Interviews have been conducted since September 2019 and will continue through April 2020 and are being analyzed with constant comparative analysis using Dedoose. Results: Patients reported overwhelmingly positive experiences at family planning clinics and were especially surprised at the ease and speed of the informed consent process. Barriers to care remain for patients in rural areas, low income patients, and patients who need specialized care. Some barriers relate to the gender binary and transphobia, which cause patients and providers to have to find “work arounds” for the ways these ideas are built into medical and insurance systems. Patients also shared their idealized visions of transition-related care that center on strong referral networks and hiring of LGBTQ staff at the clinics. Conclusion: Family planning clinics currently provide affirming and supportive transition-related care, especially those that use the informed consent model. Family planning clinics could provide increased access to transgender healthcare outside of major metropolitan areas and for transgender and gender non-conforming clients across the lifespan.

Assessment of individual and community needs for health education Diversity and culture Program planning Public health or related laws, regulations, standards, or guidelines Public health or related organizational policy, standards, or other guidelines Social and behavioral sciences