Session
Community-Based and Community-Engaged Research
APHA 2021 Annual Meeting and Expo
Abstract
Chat! Tips for conducting virtual focus groups with adolescents from Appalachia to Los Angeles
APHA 2021 Annual Meeting and Expo
Methods: MITRE conducted 55+ virtual focus groups and interviews as part of a mixed-methods evaluation of five previously proven effective pregnancy prevention programs. These programs were implemented among youth, ages 12-16 years, by 6 community organizations across 15+ sites in the U.S.
Results: Conducting virtual focus groups required adjusting traditional strategies. The differences included additional time for site training and logistics, technical set-up to reduce barriers for participants, and coordinating over-recruitment to account for ~60% of scheduled youth attending the focus groups. A unique need in the virtual setting was for a community liaison to assist with reminding youth to log onto the focus groups and providing the MITRE team with situational awareness when youth were non-responsive or experiencing difficulties. MITRE also needed a team member to work with the community liaison so they could problem-solve while the MITRE moderator welcomed and built rapport with the youth. Moderators found that youth were not often comfortable sharing their video but allowing the use of chat and using visual aides to display real-time responses were two effective ways to build rapport.
Conclusion: Virtual focus groups are an effective method in gaining youth perceptions across a wide geographic range when the moderation team allocates substantial time for coordination with participants and sites; uses a liaison to improve information flow; and maximizes the use of technology.
Approved for Public Release; Distribution Unlimited. Public Release Case Number 21-0813
Conduct evaluation related to programs, research, and other areas of practice Public health or related research Social and behavioral sciences
Abstract
Community representation: A health equity approach to the Louisiana state health assessment
APHA 2021 Annual Meeting and Expo
This innovative assessment approach is grounded in evidence-based practices and health equity frameworks to ensure an equitable, actionable, and accountable SHA. Engagement and promotional mechanisms include a communications, social media and partnership promotional toolkit and virtual meeting materials as well as a participatory data collection approach including an online community survey, community member interviews, public health leader interviews, and an Instagram photovoice campaign.
Although the Louisiana approach is designed for virtual engagement due to the COVID-19 pandemic, it can be adapted for hybrid (both in-person and virtual) engagement. The approach takes into consideration available technology, offering multiple opportunities for community members to engage including online, in person, via phone, and through social media. The goal is to meet individuals where they are and remove barriers that have prevented community members from participating in SHAs in the past.
The SHA approach was designed to ensure that the needs, priorities and strategies identified during the SHA reflect the state’s most pressing health concerns from the perspective of its residents, and generates more partner, resident, and stakeholder participation in the implementation of Louisiana’s statewide health improvement plan. The SHA will be implemented beginning in Summer 2021.
Assessment of individual and community needs for health education Communication and informatics Program planning
Abstract
Youth participatory action research: Youth-led research assessing the impact of COVID-19 on adolescents and their home environments
APHA 2021 Annual Meeting and Expo
Assessment of individual and community needs for health education Public health or related research
Abstract
“you can’t pour from an empty cup”: Using YPAR to identify mental health challenges among bipoc adolescents in Philadelphia
APHA 2021 Annual Meeting and Expo
Administer health education strategies, interventions and programs Assessment of individual and community needs for health education Public health or related research Social and behavioral sciences
Abstract
Engaging parents on twitter for participatory research on the HPV vaccine.
APHA 2021 Annual Meeting and Expo
Methods: We assembled a diverse parent advisory board (PAB) by recruiting on Twitter: six parents (5 female, 1 male) who identify as African American, South Asian-American, and white, from across six states in the U.S., including urban, suburban and rural, with children ages 11-12. Over a six-month period, we held monthly meetings with the PAB to develop personas to be used to deliver HPV vaccine messages to other parents on Twitter. Before each meeting they completed a workbook with persona development materials and targeted questions to gather extensive feedback.
Results: The PAB helped develop four personas that will be used to deliver HPV vaccine messages on Twitter: 1) Informed Altruist, 2) Real Talker, 3) Information Gatherer, and 4) Supporter. They provided expert insights and feedback on persona characteristics, lifestyle, vaccine motivations, vaccine issues, communication, contextual influences, and individual influences. The PAB suggested to highlight specific fears around vaccines (e.g., making the wrong decision or not feeling confident in a choice). They also discussed how they personally communicate with other parents around vaccines, and how we could incorporate those specific details into the personas.
Conclusion: Engaging parents on Twitter to inform research activities was important for buy-in and oversight of research activities. Their breadth of experiences and depth of understandings provided important grounding in health messaging.
Communication and informatics Diversity and culture Implementation of health education strategies, interventions and programs Public health or related research
Abstract
Cultural tailoring of health and environmental communication interventions and messages: Distinguishing process and content
APHA 2021 Annual Meeting and Expo
Methods. We review literature and describe our experiences across a series of studies developing communication interventions in the context of environment and health.
Results. Using formative data and community input (in various forms) can enhance intervention quality and impact and that tailoring or targeting of intervention content based on this process should be central to message design. We distinguish between cultural tailoring processes and cultural tailoring of content for communication interventions. For cultural tailoring processes, we describe the range of approaches to intervention design: from those led and designed by community members using participatory frameworks to those done without community input. For cultural tailoring of content, we extend earlier frameworks of message tailoring to account for the literature on persuasion and intercultural communication and specify the range of options for designing messages that account for characteristics of cultural groups.
Conclusions. Cultural tailoring of processes and content can have unique positive contributions to environmental and health campaigns. Community engagement can improve outcomes in both cases.
Advocacy for health and health education Assessment of individual and community needs for health education Communication and informatics Diversity and culture Environmental health sciences
Abstract
Consultative, stakeholder-engaged health communication research to reduce tobacco use among young adult sexual minority women
APHA 2021 Annual Meeting and Expo
Methods. Rooted in Participatory Implementation Science, we are using a consultative model, engaging recognized leaders in the area of LGBTQ+ health as Expert Advisory Committee (EAC) members. Our approach emphasizes intensive engagement every 3 to 6 months to ensure that critical study-related decisions are informed by EAC expertise without over-burdening members. As an illustration, we describe the EAC’s impact on key informant interviews with practitioners and leaders from organizations representing the target dissemination audience. The interviews (n=20) explored key contextual factors expected to drive later adoption and utilization of Project Resist’s findings.
Results. EAC members offered critical insight and support by a) providing practice-based context (e.g., future adopters’ decision-making around tobacco programning); b) revisions to the interview guide; c) participant recruitment; d) interpretation of early findings (e.g., nuances of intersectional identities that influence interpretation), and e) ideas for incorporating results into planned health communication experiments (e.g., challenges regarding the extent to which people may or may not identify with intended signifiers of LGBTQ+ community identity).
Conclusions. Ongoing collaboration with EAC members is expected to increase the usability and impact of the findings from this health communication project. Please note investigators and EAC members are co-authors on this submission.
Planning of health education strategies, interventions, and programs Public health or related research Social and behavioral sciences
Abstract
Improving social connectedness by addressing forgiveness using a social and emotional (SEL) learning model
APHA 2021 Annual Meeting and Expo
Social connectedness is a significant determinant of health and serves as a critical factor in protecting, improving, and maintaining individual and community wellbeing. Forgiveness is a tenet of all world religions, yet despite a substantial body of evidence indicating higher forgiveness scores correlate with a wide array of improved health outcomes, addressing the concept of forgiveness is largely ignored in public health promotion intervention efforts.
Methods:
A curriculum was developed by Forgive for Health Ministries, Inc. (FFHM), a 501c (3) faith-based organization in Georgia, to improve forgiveness, social connectedness, and wellbeing. The FFHM curriculum used a Social and Emotional Learning Model and was implemented through two separate, culturally appropriate programs for African American adults and youth ≤ 12 years of age. The programs consisted of virtual sessions called “Art, Tea, and Forgiveness Circles” (ATFCs) that were conducted weekly. Initially, the sessions were held in-person but changed to a virtual platform at the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Results:
From January 2020 to March 2021, FFHM conducted more than 50 weekly sessions reaching individuals across the United States, United Kingdom, and Canada. Forgiveness assessments were conducted for participants at various implementation intervals. Participants reported a reduction in anger, hostility, and depression, improved willingness to forgive, and improved social awareness and relationship skills.
Conclusion:
The ATFC methodology reflects practice-based evidence that can be used to increased social connectedness, forgiveness scores, and ultimately the health of African American adults and youth. Lessons learned from implementation strategies will be shared during this session.
Public health or related education
Abstract
Mentor growth and challenges in a community health driven undergraduate-high school student mentorship
APHA 2021 Annual Meeting and Expo
Studies analyzing the bidirectional mentee-mentor relationship often focuses unidirectionally on the mentee experience. Our study focuses on the other end of the relationship, mentor experience and growth. This study utilizes a qualitative approach, using questionnaires and virtual focus groups to assess growth in (1) interest in community health (2) professional development and (3) feeling competent as simultaneous community health educators and advocates.
Assessments revealed a significant portion of the mentors joined to empower their mentees to believe that they can influence the health of their communities. Additionally, through PEERS, mentors identified that several dimensions in the community are interdependent and that their leadership skills — specifically, adaptability and facilitating the exchange of ideas — have improved. PEERS has opened the door of opportunities to allow both undergraduate and high school students to be in touch with relevant issues in their community and helped them identify that they are more than capable of making a difference in their communities. We hope this encourages implementation of more community health-driven mentorships.
Planning of health education strategies, interventions, and programs Program planning Public health or related education Public health or related research
Abstract
“we are the forgotten community”: A qualitative study on black individuals’ perspectives on the impact of structural factors during COVID-19
APHA 2021 Annual Meeting and Expo
Methods: Qualitative data were collected through six focus groups comprising 25 community members recruited from Black neighborhoods in North St. Louis City and County across three age groups: 18-30 years, 31-59 years, and 60+ years. Analysts thematically coded transcripts using Dedoose software, and summarized coded excerpts, identifying themes and key findings.
Results: Participants reported that systemic racism caused problems for their community during the pandemic, with disparities in access to testing sites and healthcare services, and delays in getting protective equipment and information. Historical trauma, including references to Henrietta Lacks and the Tuskegee study, contributed to heightened distrust of governmental and healthcare organizations. Nearly all participants expressed vaccine hesitancy due to the history of medical injustice. Participants felt that the local and federal government needed to do more in terms of providing consistent mandates. Several participants implied that being Black was a risk factor for COVID-19 in itself. Some reported that messages emphasizing disparities could prove discouraging: “it’s like our backs against the wall.” Participants recommended providing information acknowledging racism and emphasizing accurate information about protective actions from credible sources and channels.
Conclusion: Based on participants’ perspectives, targeted and intentional efforts need to address the lack of trust in structural entities among Black people.
Administration, management, leadership Assessment of individual and community needs for health education Public health or related organizational policy, standards, or other guidelines Public health or related research