Session
Data to enhance health equity II
APHA 2024 Annual Meeting and Expo
Abstract
Stanford screenomics: An open-source platform for unobtrusive multimodal digital trace data collection from android smartphones
APHA 2024 Annual Meeting and Expo
Communication and informatics Epidemiology Public health or related research Social and behavioral sciences
Abstract
Establishing an empowerment measure for Massachusetts public health boards and assessing the socio-political influence of race and the impact of board empowerment on tobacco retail density in communities
APHA 2024 Annual Meeting and Expo
A measurement of empowerment was built based on five variables: word count associated with BoH and references to BoH within bylaws or charter; number and method of attainment of BoH seats; and fy22 budget allocated to BoH, with data sourced from a novel quantitative dataset developed from data collection for each of Massachusetts’ 351 municipalities. Linear probability modeling was performed to evaluate EI’s ability to predict the TDR for the 314 municipalities (89%) that reported a TDR, controlling for Republican 2020 presidential election percentage, race, 2022 Census population, and median income.
Municipalities with higher EI scores are associated with a higher probability of having a lower municipality TDR (p=0.0147, 95% CI= -0.4455, -0.0488). Further, municipalities with a greater percentage of white residents are associated with a higher probability of having a lower TDR in their municipality (p=0.0450, 95% CI= -0.0084, -0.0000). This research can assist local boards of health, particularly in vulnerable population communities, in enhancing their empowerment in establishing stronger policies to reduce tobacco retailer density in their community.
Administration, management, leadership Conduct evaluation related to programs, research, and other areas of practice Public health administration or related administration Public health or related public policy Systems thinking models (conceptual and theoretical models), applications related to public health
Abstract
Driving health equity through inclusive demographic data: Best practices and benefits
APHA 2024 Annual Meeting and Expo
Demographic granularity enables the identification of inequities that disproportionately affect certain groups; for example, understanding the distinct health challenges within BIPOC communities, or recognizing the unique healthcare needs of gender diverse individuals, allows for tailored interventions that are more effective and equitable.
This presentation draws on interdisciplinary perspectives from public health, reproductive healthcare, and data equity to share best practices for developing comprehensive demographic categories and implementing a roll-up procedure, which aggregates detailed data into broader categories. This ensures that specific identities are preserved while overall trends and patterns remain visible. This dual approach capacitates more accurate and equitable insights.
Through practical examples and data analysis resources this presentation will equip attendees with actionable steps to advocate for and implement more inclusive data practices within their organizations. Ultimately, this presentation aims to catalyze a paradigm shift towards data equity, ensuring all individuals are seen, heard, and represented in the data that shapes our collective future.
Communication and informatics Diversity and culture Other professions or practice related to public health Public health or related education Public health or related organizational policy, standards, or other guidelines Public health or related research
Abstract
Using advanced analytics to identify preparedness and response practices for at-risk and underserved communities: An aspr baseline analysis
APHA 2024 Annual Meeting and Expo
For this study, the evaluation team interviewed individuals across eight ASPR program areas (n=8) who had significant contact with state and local partners to understand how they conceive of equity and how they are beginning to incorporate thinking around equity into their activities. The evaluation team then designed a data analysis approach using natural language processing to analyze hundreds (n=677) of unstructured response plans and after-action reports. Finally, the team interviewed additional individuals across ASPR (n=17) to gather information about the capabilities ASPR developed during COVID-19 to meet the needs of at-risk individuals and underserved communities. Through this study, ASPR gained baseline information on the current state of response and identified promising practices that were taken to plan and care for underserved communities. This study has been critical to ASPR’s subsequent policy actions to further incorporate health equity into all of ASPR’s work. This presentation will focus upon the process and methods ASPR used to conduct this pilot study.
Communication and informatics Conduct evaluation related to programs, research, and other areas of practice Diversity and culture Program planning Provision of health care to the public Social and behavioral sciences
Abstract
Advancing equity together: Building scientific capacity and collaboration with community leaders through qualitative research training.
APHA 2024 Annual Meeting and Expo
In 2023, TPCHD partnered with the University of Washington Qualitative Research Core to design and implement qualitative data collection training for community leaders and health department staff. Three training sessions were held: two with community members (n= 58) and one with health department staff (n=26). The curriculum included facilitating focus groups and interviews, aiming to help community organizations in fulfill their goals and evaluate programs while advancing health equity.
A pre- post- survey measured participants’ knowledge and skills and general feedback about the course. An additional follow-up-survey was implemented 6-12 months after the training, assessed the application of new skills and identified further training needs. Participants were incentivized with $100 gift cards.
Post survey results indicated improvements in knowledge about qualitive research (i.e. developing interview guides, avoiding bias, member checking) and increase in confidence in their ability to collect qualitative data (i.e. conduct interviews and focus groups). Ninety five percent of those who responded to the follow-up survey reported that they believe the skills learned in the training have benefited the communities they serve. Participants were interested in future trainings to gain qualitative data analysis skills.
Assessment of individual and community needs for health education Public health or related education Social and behavioral sciences
Abstract
Promoting health equity in digital research by addressing the threat of survey bots in an online study among latinx sexual minoritized men
APHA 2024 Annual Meeting and Expo
Ethics, professional and legal requirements Public health or related nursing Social and behavioral sciences
Abstract
Exploring no show patterns: Insights from an integrated community health center
APHA 2024 Annual Meeting and Expo
This study employed a sequential mixed-methods design examining secondary data of patients’ appointments (N = ~5000), and semi-structured interviews with healthcare providers and allied professionals in an integrated care community health center.
Aggregated analysis shows 57% appointment completions, 23% cancellations, and 20% no shows. However, stratified descriptive analyses provide cues about the complexity of no-shows revealing temporal dynamics and variations across different service domains. The findings offer insights into patients’ service utilization decisions and possible preferences. The healthcare and allied professionals’ interviews suggest the underlying factors for no shows are multifaceted, highlighting system or agency specific factors as well as social determinants of health.
The findings also highlight service gaps and underscore the importance of tailored interventions and technological innovations in reducing no-shows and mitigating their effects across different service domains.
Administration, management, leadership Diversity and culture Other professions or practice related to public health Provision of health care to the public Public health or related research Systems thinking models (conceptual and theoretical models), applications related to public health
Abstract
Multi-sector community partnership engagement in refining measures of SDOH success
APHA 2024 Annual Meeting and Expo
Measure development involved a literature review, prioritization process, and multisector review and scoring of 59 measures covering all 5 domains. Thirteen multisector community partnerships (MCPs) conducted the review, applying a real-world public health practice lens to assess the relevance and burden of each measure. MCPs’ ratings were analyzed to create summary scores for each measure, and open-ended feedback was synthesized using rapid qualitative analysis.
Feedback from the MCPs raised issues of relevance, burden of data collection, and equity. Reviewers emphasized the need for measures to align with the equity goals of the community, the value of measuring quality and quantity, and the importance of considering MCPs’ scope of practice. Community review informed refinement of NCCDPHP criteria used for selecting and prioritizing measures.
Reflection on what matters to communities may be important when monitoring progress on SDOH program initiatives. Engaging communities in the review of measures may help advance health equity by leveraging community expertise, sharing power with communities, and creating a system of accountability for equitable intervention approaches.
Chronic disease management and prevention Conduct evaluation related to programs, research, and other areas of practice Diversity and culture Public health or related research
Abstract
Content analysis of social determinants of health accelerator plans using artificial intelligence; A case study of a novel data analysis tool to advance health equity
APHA 2024 Annual Meeting and Expo
Methods: Our team sampled four publicly-available, SDOH accelerator plans to explore approaches to expedite content analysis of real-world public health documents. We compared our analysis to GPT-4o abstraction performance on 20 data elements including identifying SDOH focus areas, funder required sections (e.g., purpose, workplan), and descriptions of priority populations and leadership teams between and across the 4 plans. We also compared resources required for each method.
Results: In preliminary results, GPT-4o demonstrated overall abstraction accuracy of 79% (n= 17 errors). Eight errors were major fabrications and GPT-4o missed details for complex abstractions, such as describing the priority population and leadership team. On average, GPT-4o abstraction required fewer hours than study team abstraction, but resource savings diminished when accounting for time for developing prompts and identifying/correcting errors.
Conclusion: AI tools can help save public health professionals’ time on tasks that support continuous program improvement, including content analysis of strategic plans. However, as tools evolve, users should plan for investing time in (1) refining prompts, because the accuracy of abstraction may be dependent on how specific prompts are to the program being used and (2) quality checking, particularly for the abstraction and synthesis of complex details.
Conduct evaluation related to programs, research, and other areas of practice Other professions or practice related to public health Public health or related education Public health or related nursing Public health or related research